In this episode of Premier Unbelievable?, host Vince Vitale moderates a riveting debate that tackles one of the most profound questions in philosophy, religion, and ethics: Can we be 'good' without God? 🤔✨ Dr. Michael Shermer, renowned skeptic and author of The Moral Arc, joins Glen Scrivener, Anglican minister, author of The Air We Breathe, speaker and filmmaker who directs the charity Speak Life, to explore the origins and foundations of morality. Together, they address whether human morality is the product of secular, scientific, and cultural evolution 🧠🌍, or whether it is deeply rooted in divine principles, particularly those derived from Christianity ✝️🙏 .
This conversation explores key arguments on both sides. Shermer argues that morality can be understood through secular reasoning 🌐 with frameworks like utilitarianism and deontology 📜, and that moral values evolve over time through cultural shifts and reason. He contends that religion has not always been a reliable moral guide and that objective moral values can exist independently of God, emerging from evolutionary and cultural processes. Shermer emphasizes that moral progress, such as individual rights from the Enlightenment 🕊️, often arises from philosophical reasoning and societal change, not divine command.
On the other hand, Scrivener argues that many moral principles, especially the inherent value of every individual, are rooted in Christian theology ✝️. He asserts that human rights and justice ⚖️ are inseparable from Christian teachings, which have historically shaped modern morality. Scrivener highlights Christianity’s role in moral progress, such as the abolition of slavery and the concept of universal human worth. While recognizing cultural and philosophical influences, he argues that without a divine source, the foundation of absolute moral values is unstable.
#MoralityDebate #GoodWithoutGod #PhilosophyAndReligion #MichaelShermer #GlenScrivener #ChristianityVsAtheism #SecularMorality #FaithAndReason #theenlightenment #humanrights #MoralProgress #EthicsDebate #SpeakLife #UnbelievablePodcast
For Glen Scrivener
Speak Life [ Ссылка ]
YouTube: @SpeakLifeMedia
X: @glenscrivener
For Michael Shermer
[ Ссылка ]
YouTube: @skepticmagazine
X: @michaelshermer
Further Reading:
The Science of Good and Evil: Why People Cheat, Gossip, Care, Share, and Follow the Golden Rule, Michael Shermer - [ Ссылка ] Moral Arc, Michael Shermer - [ Ссылка ] Air We Breathe: How We All Came to Believe in Freedom, Kindness, Progress, and Equality, Glen Scrivener - [ Ссылка ] To See Life: A Guide In 321, Glen Scrivener - [ Ссылка ]
• Subscribe to the Unbelievable? podcast: [ Ссылка ]
• More shows, free eBook & newsletter: [ Ссылка ]
• For live events: [ Ссылка ]
• For online learning: [ Ссылка ]
• Support us in the USA: [ Ссылка ]
• Support us in the rest of the world: [ Ссылка ]
