SITHARAMAN JI माफ़ करो, BHARAT में रहना कर दिया IMPOSSIBLE | Ep- 1665 | Umesh Agarwal | Sumeet Jain

*Critique of India's GST System by Chetan Bhagat: A Professional Analysis*

*Introduction*
* Renowned author and columnist Chetan Bhagat's December 25, 2024, article in The Times of India critiques India's Goods and Services Tax (GST) system. Using relatable examples, such as the varying tax rates on popcorn, Bhagat highlights how the GST system deviates from its original intent, creating inefficiencies that hinder economic growth.


*Key Points of Analysis*

*1. Illustrating Complexity with Popcorn*

*Example of Tax Rates:*

* Plain or salted popcorn: Taxed at 5%.

* Caramelized popcorn: Taxed at 18% due to sugar content.


*Analysis:*

* This disparity reflects arbitrary classifications, showcasing inefficiencies in the GST framework.

* Treating similar items differently reveals a flawed policy mindset that prioritizes bureaucratic complexity over simplicity.


*2. Criticism of Policymakers' Mindset*

*Desire for Control:*

* Bhagat points out that policymakers and bureaucrats prioritize control and revenue extraction over simplicity.

* Overly complex tax policies reflect a reluctance to embrace reform.


*Moral Judgments in Taxation:*

* Higher taxes on enjoyable items, like caramelized popcorn, stem from a paternalistic view of luxury.

* This outdated mindset discourages quality consumption, which is vital for economic modernization.


*3. Failure of the Original GST Vision*

*Original Intent:*

* GST was introduced in 2017 with four slabs (5%, 12%, 18%, 28%) to simplify indirect taxation.

* It aimed to unify and streamline India’s tax system.


*Deviations from Vision:*

*Addition of Cesses:*
* New cesses have complicated the system, making compliance burdensome.

*Multiple Tax Slabs:*
* Maintaining multiple slabs has made GST nearly as complex as the old tax regime.


*4. Economic Impacts of GST’s Flaws*

*Discouraging Quality Consumption:*

* High taxes on quality goods deter consumption, a critical driver of economic growth.


*Deterring Modernization:*

* Policymakers view modern comforts as luxuries, creating obstacles to India’s transition to a developed economy.


*Burden on Businesses:*

* SMEs face compliance challenges due to the intricacy of the tax system, affecting growth and competitiveness.


*Proposed Reforms by Chetan Bhagat*

*Simplification of Tax Slabs:*

* Limit slabs to two (e.g., one for essentials and another for non-essentials).


*Elimination of Cesses:*

* Remove cesses to establish a straightforward tax structure.


*Shift in Policymaking Focus:*

* Prioritize fostering quality consumption and economic growth over maximizing revenue extraction.


*Adopt a Forward-Thinking Approach:*

* Embrace policies that encourage modernization and make India business-friendly.


*Conclusion*

* Chetan Bhagat’s critique emphasizes the urgent need to revisit India’s GST system. Simplifying tax slabs, eliminating cesses, and modernizing policymaking can restore GST to its original vision of being a "Good and Simple Tax."
* These reforms are crucial for fostering economic growth, enabling businesses, and positioning India as a global economic powerhouse.
* Bhagat's analysis serves as a call to action for policymakers to align tax policies with the nation’s developmental aspirations.

EMAIL: Coffeewithsumeetjain@gmail.com


👉Instagram: [ Ссылка ]==

👉TWITTER: [ Ссылка ]

👉TELEGRAM GROUP [ Ссылка ]




#Sumeetjain #sumitjain #modi #india #bharat #indiashinning #worldorder #China #pakistanreaction #pakistanmediacrying #pakistanfunnyreaction #pakistanarmyfails #ttp #bla #balochistan #pok #boycottcongress #rahulgandi #poledancersonia #geopolitics
#currentaffairs #currentissue #rahulgandhi #congressmuktbharat

свернуть