Simpson was a three-time All-American, Army's only three-time All-American. He finished his career ranked second with 134 career victories and 54 career pins. His mark of 20 pins in a single season stands as the second-most on the single-season charts in program history. Following his senior year, he was the 2005 AAA Award Winner, A prestigious Army Athletic Association Award that is awarded annually to the male and female cadet who displays the "most valuable service to intercollegiate athletics during a career as a cadet." Simpson is also Army's only three-time EIWA Champion.
