In this episode of New Ideal Live, and in the context of ongoing events in Israel and Gaza, Onkar Ghate and Elan Journo discuss how to think about civilian casualties in war.
Among the topics covered:
● Why the brutal nature of war should not be sanitized, glamorized, or whitewashed;
● Why winning requires doing everything necessary to bring an end to the enemy’s military and political leadership;
● How Hamas uses its subjects as human shields, hoping to deter Israel from defending itself and turn wider opinion against Israel;
● How to think about the moral and causal responsibility of civilians for the aggression of their government;
● Why a proper concern for innocent people and allies in enemy territory cannot jeopardize overall war aims;
● Why war must not be thought of as punishment for a criminal act but as the total ending of an enemy regime’s power to attack;
● That Hamas’s goal is not freedom for Palestinians but the annihilation of Israel and the establishment of a religious dictatorship;
● Why it’s wrong to apply a standard of “proportionality” to military actions taken in self-defense;
● How altruism causes observers to put emotional reactions to images of suffering above concerns with justice and self-defense;
● Why Israel and the West’s appeasement of evil makes them partly culpable for the attacks they now face.
Relevant to the discussion is “Ayn Rand on the Death of Innocents in War,” ([ Ссылка ]) a recently released video on the ARI YouTube page, which documents Rand’s extemporaneous comments on the issue of civilian casualties in war.
This episode was broadcast live on October 18, 2023.
0:00:00 Introduction
0:00:24 The brutal nature of war
0:04:45 What does winning require
0:09:21 The purpose of Hamas’s human shields
0:12:33 Responsibility of civilians for their government
0:17:12 Proper concern for innocent people and war aims
0:30:18 War as the total ending of an enemy’s power
0:38:42 Annihilation of Israel as the real goal of Hamas
0:40:49 “Proportionality” as not applying to military actions
0:45:00 Emotional reactions above concerns with justice
0:51:32 Israel and the West’s appeasement of evil
