Was the Quran preserved? No. I am going to share a clip from a discussion I had with my friend Abdullah Gondal on the preservation of the Quran.
Full version: [ Ссылка ]
👉 IMPORTANT: SUBSCRIBE TO MY NEW CHANNEL HERE: [ Ссылка ] 👈
► My blog: [ Ссылка ]
CORRECTION: At 9:12 We made a mistake. يُقَتِّلُونَ does not mean "they fought"; it actually means "they killed", just as "يَقْتُلُونَ" does. The meaning is the same in both verses, regardless of the word being used.
The ones that do know often downplay it and say the meaning doesn't change - much. But the fact that differences even exist should raise eyebrows.
How did we end up here? According to the hadith, Allah revealed the Quran in 7 dialects of Arabia to make it easy for memorizing, but then it ended up causing more confusion and problems after Muhammad died, so Uthman was forced to destroy all the variants, but still some trivial differences were left and that's how we got the 10 qiraat.
Does that make any sense?
We're not talking differences in manuscripts here, that's a whole other can of worms. These differences are all in agreed upon variations of the Quran today.
The preservation of the Quran is dubious. What we see are not trivial differences, and is exactly what we would expect to see with a book that was NOT preserved properly. Differences in letters, additional words or words missing.
The fracturing of a book in this manner is exactly what we would expect to find with an oral tradition that was not written down, and a book not preserved properly.
The so called hadith which said the Quran was REVEALED in 7 dialects came 200-300 years after Muhammad, and was probably fabricated for damage control. How else would you explain this book being perfect and also there being multiple versions of it.
In conclusion, the Quran was not preserved. The differences we see today are exactly what we would expect to see with a book that was NOT preserved properly. Please check out our full discussion on was the Quran preserved for more details.
References:
[ Ссылка ]
[ Ссылка ]
Ещё видео!